The Truth About the ‘Spark’ in Relationships: Why Lasting Love Is More Than Instant Chemistry

The elusive “spark.” That moment when two people’s eyes meet across a crowded room — instant chemistry. Is it love at first sight? Or something else…?

As much as I think we would all love to believe that our soulmate is somewhere out there (we just haven’t made eye contact with them yet), the reality is a little less enticing. That sensation of instant chemistry or the “spark” can be misleading and is not the best indicator to use when deciding whether to continue seeing someone.

This idea of an instant, electrifying connection has seeped into our collective understanding of what love should feel like. But is the “spark” really the best indicator of a potential lifelong partner? Or is it just a romanticized myth that can lead us astray?

couples counseling, individual relationship counseling

What Is the “Spark”?

The “spark” is often described as a powerful feeling of attraction, excitement, and chemistry when you first meet someone. Think butterflies in your stomach, rapid heartbeat, and an overwhelming desire to know everything about this person.

couples counseling, individual relationship therapy

What is Really Behind the “Spark”?

Don’t get me wrong — the “spark” is a very real feeling and can be explained by a combination of biological and psychological factors:

  • Dopamine Rush: When we meet someone new and exciting, our brains release dopamine, the neurotransmitter associated with pleasure and reward. This can create a feeling of euphoria, making us feel like we’ve found something — or someone — extraordinary.

  • Evolutionary Attraction: From an evolutionary perspective, humans are wired to seek out mates who will contribute to the survival and reproduction of the species. The “spark” might be our brain’s way of signaling that we’ve found someone with desirable traits, such as physical attractiveness, vitality, or social status.

  • Confirmation Bias: Societal conditioning primes us to believe that love = feeling a “spark.” We are therefore more likely to interpret these strong initial feelings as a sign of true love (i.e., “love at first sight”). As a result, we may prioritize relationships that begin with a sensation of intense chemistry, disregard relationships that do not begin with the elusive “spark” and overlook potential signs of incompatibility (or even red flags).

  • The Mere Exposure Effect: The mere exposure effect refers to the psychological phenomenon in which people develop preferences for things simply because they have been exposed to them repeatedly. The mere exposure effect operates on a deeper level, where even an initial meeting might feel charged with a “spark” if there are subconscious elements of familiarity at play. Even though the person is new to you, they may possess qualities, behaviors, or even physical traits that resemble people you have been exposed to before — whether through friends, family, past partners, or even cultural references like movies or TV shows. Further, humans are wired to prefer things that feel familiar because they signal safety and predictability. If the person you meet shares cultural, linguistic, or social similarities with people you’ve previously interacted with, your brain may quickly associate them with positive past experiences, leading to that spark of instant attraction. This rapid assessment might happen within seconds, based on subtle cues such as mannerisms, voice, or shared interests. Paradoxically, if our past childhood experiences or relationships were chaotic, toxic, and/or turbulent, the “spark” may be pulling us toward partners with characteristics similar characteristics or traits. Basically, when chaos feels like home, we are drawn to more chaos — because it is what we know.

The Downside of Chasing the “Spark”

While feeling a “spark” can be exciting, it’s not necessarily a reliable foundation for a lasting relationship. Here’s why:

1. The Spark Can Fade

The intense feelings associated with the “spark” often diminish over time as the novelty wears off. What initially felt like a deep connection might turn out to be fleeting infatuation. When the dopamine rush subsides, we might find that we don’t have much in common with the person or that they aren’t as compatible as we initially thought.

2. The Spark Can Be Misleading

The “spark” is sometimes mistaken for love when it’s actually driven by factors like physical attraction or the allure of the unknown. This can lead us into relationships with people who might not be the best fit for us in the long run. We might overlook red flags or incompatibilities because we’re blinded by the initial chemistry.

3. The Spark Can Create Unrealistic Expectations

When we place too much emphasis on the “spark,” we might set ourselves up for disappointment. If we expect every relationship to begin with fireworks, we might overlook the potential for love to grow slowly and steadily over time. This can cause us to prematurely dismiss relationships that have the potential for deep, lasting connection simply because they didn’t start with a feeling of electricity.

What Really Matters in a Relationship

Instead of focusing solely on the “spark,” it’s important to consider other qualities that contribute to a healthy, fulfilling relationship:

1. Emotional Compatibility

Emotional compatibility involves being able to understand, support, and empathize with each other. It’s about feeling safe to express your feelings and knowing that your partner will be there to listen and respond with care. Relationships built on emotional compatibility are more likely to withstand the challenges of life because they are rooted in mutual respect and understanding.

2. Shared Values and Goals

Having shared values and goals is crucial for long-term compatibility. When partners align on important aspects of life, such as family, finances, and future aspirations, they are better equipped to build a life together. This alignment creates a strong foundation that can support the relationship through ups and downs.


3. Mutual Respect and Trust

Respect and trust are the cornerstones of any successful relationship. Without them, even the strongest “spark” will eventually fizzle out. A relationship based on mutual respect and trust is one where both partners feel valued, heard, and secure.


4. Growth Over Time

Love isn’t just about the initial spark — it’s about how the relationship evolves over time. Healthy relationships grow deeper as partners get to know each other on a more profound level, navigate challenges together, and continue to choose each other day after day. This growth is often slow and steady, but it leads to a more enduring connection.

Reframing the “Spark”

It’s important to recognize that the “spark” isn’t a definitive marker of a successful relationship. While it can be a positive sign, it shouldn’t be the sole criterion for pursuing a relationship. Instead, consider the “spark” as one of many factors that contribute to a relationship’s potential.

Real love often develops gradually, as two people build a foundation of trust, respect, and shared experiences. The slow burn of a relationship that grows over time can be far more rewarding than the flash of a “spark” that quickly fades.


Conclusion

The myth of the “spark” has led many people to prioritize instant chemistry over the qualities that truly matter in a lasting relationship. While it’s natural to want to feel that initial excitement, it’s important to look beyond the “spark” and focus on building a connection that is rooted in emotional compatibility, shared values, and mutual respect. In the end, the most enduring love stories aren’t the ones that start with fireworks — they’re the ones that grow slowly, steadily, and deeply over time.


Individual Relationship Therapy Denver, Colorado


It’s okay to be single and not happy about it! As social beings, we all want to love and to be loved, our skilled therapists at Authentic Connections Therapy and Wellness can help you feel optimistic and supported while navigating your feelings around dating and relationships. Follow the steps below to get started.

​​

1. We encourage you to get to know a little bit about our therapists, their specializations, and their credentials. Get to know our therapists here.

2. If you think Individual relationship therapy with a focus on dating is for you, reach out to us! You can use our convenient online consultation scheduling here.

3. Begin the exciting journey of understanding your difficult emotions to forge lasting, healthy, and fulfilling relationships!


We hope to hear from you soon!

Dr. Megan Rinderer

Dr. Rinderer works with clients who feel unfulfilled with their life and relationships. If you want to better understand how past trauma may be keeping you stuck in the same pattern, Dr. Rinderer would be a great fit. She excels at helping her clients understand their "stuckness" and identify a new path forward. Her clients describe her as easy to open up to and trust, and that she balances being straightforward and not "coming on too strong". She specializes in working with trauma, sexual intimacy after trauma, relationship concerns, couples, and social anxiety. Dr. Rinderer also accepts Aetna and Lyra for Colorado residents. 

https://www.authenticconnectionstherapyandwellness.com/dr-megan-rinderer
Previous
Previous

Pruning and Blooming: Embrace the Psychological and Physiological Renewal of Spring

Next
Next

Navigating Marriage: Practical Tips for Couples Adjusting to Life After the Wedding