When Anxious Meets Avoidant: 5 Key Tips for a Healthier Relationship
Do you often feel like you’re pouring yourself wholly into a relationship, only to find yourself second-guessing yourself, craving more closeness, and feeling like you're chasing someone who pulls away? Or perhaps you’ve experienced the opposite—longing for space, desiring independence, or feeling suffocated by a partner’s constant need for reassurance and connection. If this sounds familiar, you may be experiencing the complex dynamics of anxious and avoidant attachment styles. These two styles tend to attract each other - creating a relationship that can feel like a constant emotional tug-of-war.
Understanding Anxious and Avoidant Attachment:
Anxious Attachment: People with anxious attachment often have a deep fear of abandonment. They tend to crave closeness and intimacy, and they are highly attuned to the moods and feelings of their partners. When they feel disconnected or uncertain, anxiety can spike. They might constantly seek reassurance, question their partner’s commitment, and become preoccupied with the relationship.
Avoidant Attachment: In contrast, those with avoidant attachment deeply fear rejection. They might feel overwhelmed by emotional intimacy and often keep their distance to protect themselves from feeling vulnerable. Individuals with avoidant attachment tend to downplay the importance of relationships or avoid emotional closeness altogether to preserve their sense of freedom.
The Push and Pull of Anxious-Avoidant Dynamics
When someone with an anxious attachment style dates someone with an avoidant attachment style, the result is often a cycle of emotional push and pull.
The Anxious Partner: The anxious partner desires closeness and often wants to deepen the emotional connection. They might interpret their partner’s need for space or emotional distance as a sign that something is wrong. They may become anxious, questioning whether their partner truly cares about them. This fear can lead them to seek reassurance, reapproach conversations or arguments over and over, or express dissatisfaction in ways that can feel overwhelming to the avoidant partner.
The Avoidant Partner: The avoidant partner, on the other hand, can feel smothered or trapped by the anxious partner’s intensity. The more the anxious partner seeks closeness and reassurance, the more the avoidant may feel the urge to withdraw. The avoidant partner will pull away, emotionally or physically, leading the anxious partner to feel even more anxious and insecure. Avoidant individuals may also minimize or shut down conversations about emotions, leaving the anxious partner feeling frustrated or misunderstood.
This creates a cycle where the anxious partner peruses (pushes for greater connection) and the avoidant partner distances (withdraws); the more each partner pushes or withdraws, the stronger the cycle becomes.
Why Do They Attract Each Other?
Despite the challenges, anxious-avoidant partnerships are extremely common. Anxious-avoidant pairs often form because, perhaps on a subconscious level, they each fulfill something the other person lacks.
The anxious partner craves the kind of emotional connection and validation that the avoidant partner tends to withhold. The anxious partner might see the avoidant as a challenge, believing that if they can just get closer, they’ll feel more secure and loved. Anxious individuals may admire their avoidant partner’s stoicism, ability to use logic to problem-solve, or autonomous self-reliance.
The avoidant partner, in turn, might be attracted to the anxious partner’s intensity and emotional energy. The anxious partner's neediness, while overwhelming at times, can also provide a sense of being needed or desired. For the avoidant partner, this can feel like a form of validation—without having to put in the effort of providing deep emotional intimacy themselves. Avoidant individuals may admire their anxious partner’s warmth, innate intuition, and ability to connect with others.
On a deeper level, both parties in an anxious-avoidant partnership are playing out patterns that were likely formed in childhood, based on early attachment experiences with caregivers. The anxious partner may have experienced inconsistent care or emotional availability growing up, leading to a fear of abandonment in adulthood. The avoidant partner may have been raised in an environment where emotional closeness was either unavailable or perceived as unsafe, leading to a reliance on emotional self-sufficiency.
Common Struggles of an Anxious-Avoidant Dynamic:
Communication Breakdown: One of the biggest struggles in an anxious-avoidant pairing is communication. The anxious partner may struggle to express their needs in a way that feels calm and regulated, often coming across as “overly emotional” or needy to the avoidant partner. The avoidant partner, who tends to shut down or withdraw when emotions get too intense, may struggle to articulate their feelings or acknowledge the anxious partner’s needs.
Fear of Abandonment vs. Fear of Closeness: The anxious partner’s fear of abandonment can lead to clinginess, making the avoidant partner feel trapped or suffocated. On the other hand, the avoidant partner’s fear of closeness can make the anxious partner feel unloved or rejected, further intensifying their need for reassurance.
Emotional Intensity: Because of the mismatch in emotional needs, the relationship can feel exhausting. The anxious partner’s emotional intensity can trigger the avoidant partner’s need to withdraw, and vice versa. This can create a constant sense of instability, which may lead to feelings of frustration, resentment, or burnout for both partners.
Breaking the Cycle: Tips for Making It Work
While the anxious-avoidant dynamic can be challenging, it is not impossible to navigate. With awareness and effort, both partners can break free from the cycle and build a healthier, more secure relationship.
Awareness and Understanding: The first step in breaking the cycle is recognizing the patterns at play. Both partners need to understand their own attachment styles and how they impact the way they show up within the relationship. Awareness allows each partner to be more compassionate and patient with each other’s needs.
Open and Honest Communication: Communication is key. The anxious partner can learn to express their needs in a way that is calm and grounded, without overwhelming the avoidant partner. The avoidant partner, in turn, can practice being more open and responsive to the anxious partner’s emotional needs, even if it feels uncomfortable.
Setting Boundaries: It’s important for both partners to set healthy boundaries. The anxious partner may need to give the avoidant partner more space without feeling abandoned, while the avoidant partner can make an effort to engage in emotional intimacy, even if it feels vulnerable.
Seek Therapy Together: Couples therapy, especially with a therapist that specializes in attachment theory, can be a great resource for helping both partners understand their relationship dynamics and implement healthier ways to connect.
Self-Awareness and Healing: Finally, both partners can benefit from individual self-work. The anxious partner may need to work on building their own sense of self-worth and emotional regulation, while the avoidant partner might benefit from exploring their fears around closeness and vulnerability.
Anxious and avoidant attachment styles can create challenging dynamics in relationships, but they also offer an opportunity for significant growth. By understanding the underlying fears and needs driving each partner’s behavior, and learning how to communicate in a way that supports each individual’s emotional needs, an anxious-avoidant partnership can evolve into a fulfilling and secure connection.
Attachment Based Therapy Denver, Colorado
Even with the best of intentions, we can struggle to understand our own and our partner’s relationship triggers. This does not mean that you have a bad relationship or that the relationship should end. All couples should seek professional support at some point in their relationship to make sure their relationship is well taken care of! If you find yourself consistently forming unhealthy relationships, our skilled therapists at Authentic Connections Therapy and Wellness can help you understand the behaviors behind those unhealthy choices. Follow the steps below to get started.
1. We encourage you to get to know a little bit about our therapists, their specializations, and their credentials. Get to know our therapists here.
2. If you think Attachment Based Therapy is for you, reach out to us! You can use our convenient online consultation scheduling here.
3. Begin the exciting journey of understanding your relationships to forge a lasting, healthy, and fulfilling relationship!
We hope to hear from you soon!
